The 5 Best Thermal Carafe Coffee Makers

carafe coffee maker
Thermal carafe coffee maker

There is no better way to keep your coffee hot than with a thermal carafe. While some people are crazy about single-serve coffee machines and automatic pod brewers, there are still some of us who prefer using a good ol’ fashion thermal carafe coffeemaker.

Most of the amazing coffeemakers on our list are new and improved versions of the traditional brewer. Each impressive model comes with a thermal carafe capable of brewing a full pot of rich, tasty coffee. Our job with this comparison guide is to find out which coffeemaker is the best, and which comes with the best thermal carafe.

Top Pick Overview

Cuisinart Classic & Black & Decker

While our main pick must be the Classic Thermal Programmable Coffeemaker from Cuisinart, the 12-Cup Thermal Coffeemaker from Black & Decker is a real close second. Both these machines produce great coffee, but the Cuisinart comes with the best thermal carafe.

Cuisinart Classic Thermal
Level up your experience with the 10 Cup, Programmable, double-walled thermal carafe by Cuisinart
Thermal Carafe
1 - 10 Cups
Self Cleaning
Auto Shut-Off
24-hour auto brew
8” L x 10.2” W x 14” H
3 Year Warranty
4,600+ reviews!
Check Price
Black and Decker Thermal
Keep your custom brew hot throughout the day with Black+Decker's stainless steel thermal carafe
Thermal Carafe
1 - 12 Cups
Manual Clean
Auto Shut-Off
24-hour auto brew
8” L x 11” W x 11.5” H
2 Year Warranty
4,300+ reviews!
Check Price

Now, the Cuisinart is a little more expensive, roughly $25 to be exact, but it is well worth the extra cash. You get more features, the best thermal carafe, and reliable pre-programming for that special wake up coffee. The Black & Decker offers a larger carafe, but who has the time to guzzle 12 whole cups of coffee in one sitting?

Both coffeemakers come with an automatic brew setting, an automatic shutoff setting, and a brew pause setting. And while the control panel looks more futuristic on the Black & Decker, we like the traditional feel of the Cuisinart better.

Each machine comes with a double-walled thermal carafe to keep coffee perfectly hot, but the Black & Decker’s thermal carafe is exactly 2 cups larger than the one from Cuisinart. While some people may appreciate the extra space, we think it makes the whole machine a little too bulky.

One aspect we really enjoy is that the Cuisinart coffeemaker comes not only in black with a silver control panel, but also in stunning all-white. This looks particularly impressive in a clean, modern kitchen. Cuisinart’s thermal carafe is also more appealing because it’s glass, unlike the Black & Decker’s outdated stainless carafe.

Finally, the Black & Decker doesn’t come with a self-cleaning feature. The Cuisinart does. What do you think, is a coffeemaker that cleans itself worth an extra couple of dollars?

1. Cuisinart Classic Thermal Programmable Coffeemaker

Editors Choice


If you are a fan of the traditional coffeemaker, you are going to love the Classic Thermal Programmable Coffeemaker from Cuisinart. In fact, we believe this to be the overall best on our list. It is definitely the one with the best thermal carafe.

Why is this coffeemaker so great? Well, it cleans itself. This feature alone is incredible. The machine also comes with a permanent gold tone coffee filter to reduce waste. No more paper filters clogging up your garbage.

The thermal carafe stores a full 10 cups of coffee and keeps your precious caffeine heated at just the right temperature. That means you can slowly drink cup after cup without needing to reheat the coffee.

With its 24-hour programmability, this machine is an early riser’s best friend. Simply place the coffee grinds in the top, ensure the water tank is full, and program your coffee for whatever time you wake up. You will have a hot carafe full of coffee waiting for you. It really is that simple.

If you aren’t in the mood for a full 10 cups of coffee, you can easily set this machine anywhere between 1 and 4 cups. There is no need to waste coffee grinds with the thermal Programmable Coffeemaker from Cuisinart.


  • Completely automatic w/ self-cleaning power
  • Specialized charcoal water filter
  • 24-hour programmable
  • Thermal carafe is double-wall insulated
  • 1-4 cup settings
  • Coffee tastes better with the gold tone filter

We like

  • The classic look is refreshing
  • It is easy to program
  • Thermal carafe keeps coffee at perfect temperature
  • Comes in a simplistic white colour

We don’t like

  • Not as convenient as an automatic pod brewer
  • Clock is very small
  • Annoying to scrub the large thermal carafe

Check Todays Price

2. Black & Decker 12-Cup Thermal Coffeemaker

Black & Decker is a great company. They make all kinds of household products, including one of our favorite thermal coffeemakers with one of the best thermal carafes on the market.

It’s true that if you buy this machine you are not going to be wowing your neighbours with a space-age coffeemaker that talks to you and cleans the floors. Nevertheless, you can rest assured knowing that with the Black & Decker 12-CupThermal Coffeemaker you are going to wake up to the sweet smell of freshly brewed coffee every morning.

This is thanks to the machine’s handy programmable feature, allowing you to set the exact time that your coffee is brewed. It takes the hassle away from coffee making in the morning, allowing your coffee to brew a cool ten minutes before your alarm goes off. Now that’s serious convenience!

And at such an unbeatable price – it’s almost impossible not to buy this coffeemaker. It comes with a double-walled, vacuum-sealed, 12-cup thermal carafe to keep your coffee hot. The carafe also has a no-spill lid for easy pouring.

All of this for only $50 at the time of writing! We’re talking quick-touch programing on the simple user interface, a washable brew basket, a special showerhead water dispenser for extracting full flavours from your coffee. The list goes on!


  • Special strength selector for strong coffee
  • Double-walled & vacuum-sealed thermal carafe
  • Showerhead-style water dispenser for max flavour
  • Brew basket is washable
  • Compact and easy to store
  • Thermal carafe has a wide mouth for easy cleaning

We like

  • Massive carafe for serious coffee drinking
  • Thermal carafe is double walled w/ no-spill spout
  • Easy & futuristic menu interface
  • Pre-programable is a must

We don’t like

  • Not ultra-high quality, but great price
  • Screen is very small
  • 12-cup thermal carafe seems too big

Check Todays Price

3. Cuisinart Grind-and-Brew Thermal 10-Cup Automatic Coffeemaker

For just over $100, the Cuisinart Grind & Brew Thermal 10-Cup Automatic Coffeemaker is an affordable revolution in coffee-making technology. This is not the most luxurious machine, but you get a whole heap of quality features at a very low price.

For features, you can expect full programmability, a sharp LCD display with an easily identifiable on/off indicator. You can turn the grinding option off with one push of a button. You can even fill the water reservoir with the convenient release button.

The removable pieces of this machine can be washed safely in the dishwasher, including the gold tone coffee filter and the included measuring scoop. Plus, the thermal carafe has an ergonomic handle, a 10-cup capacity, and a dripless spout that makes pouring coffee easier than ever.

The icing on the cake is, of course, the integrated grinder. This baby really works. Pour in the beans, set the machine to brew, then wait while the machine grinds the beans, filters the water through the fresh grinds, and miraculously pours coffee straight into the thermal carafe. It is all done in one automatic process.

Why is this great? Because coffee beans lose their flavour after they’ve been grinded. By using this excellent coffeemaker from Cuisinart, your thermal carafe is always going to be filled with the freshest coffee money can buy – straight from the bean!


  • Integrated bean grinder
  • 100% programmable 24 hours
  • Thermal carafe is double-walled & stainless steel
  • BPA free
  • Permanent filter to reduce waste
  • Includes scoop/charcoal water filter/gold tone filter

We like

  • Grind & Brew feature makes freshest coffee
  • The price-to-features ratio is spot on
  • Comes with everything you need
  • Thermal carafe is topnotch & BPA free

We don’t like

  • Looks primitive & cheap
  • Has atrocious reviews online
  • Not that durable

Check Todays Price

4. Cuisinart Programmable Automatic Brew-and-Serve 12-Cup Thermal Coffeemaker

Thousands of people all over the world agree, Cuisinart makes good coffee. Their Programmable Automatic Brew & Serve 12-Cup Thermal Coffeemaker is another example of how Cuisinart is dominating the industry with smart, simple designs made to appease coffee drinkers everywhere.

This unit is pretty barebones. In truth, it doesn’t care about anything except making you delicious coffee. The thermal carafe is stainless-steel, 12-cup capable, and doubled walled to ensure coffee is kept at the ideal temperature until you’re ready to drink it.

While this model may not come with a fancy grinder, who needs one anyway? Simply pour in the grinds, hit the button, and enjoy a beautiful pot of coffee in mere minutes. With the programmable feature, you will always have a cup ready when you wake up or when you walk in the door after a long day of work. This coffeemaker simply works.

For simplistic brewing while keeping coffee a hassle-free activity, this automatic brewer is right for you. It costs next to nothing, so it won’t hurt your wallet. Plus, the thermal carafe is big enough to brew a cup of coffee for the whole family. It is even easy enough for the dog to use!


  • Stainless-steel thermal carafe
  • Comes included with instruction booklet
  • Automatic w/ full programmability
  • Slim and compact design
  • Window for easy identification of water level
  • Simplistic menu configuration

We like

  • Special technology keeps coffee fresher for longer
  • Thermal carafe can hold 12 cups
  • Cost is under $100
  • Simple model from Cuisinart, no bells or whistles

We don’t like

  • Feels a little too simple
  • No extra special features
  • Thermal carafe looks a little silly

Check Todays Price

5. Ninja Hot and Cold Brewed System

Ninja Hot and Cold Brewed System

Ninja has created the ultimate luxury brewing system. Talk about a versatile coffeemaker, their Hot & Cold Brewed System does literally everything that you could ask for in terms of coffee and tea.

The machine comes with separated baskets for the coffee and tea to keep everything organized. It allows you to brew six different sizes, ranging from a single cup of Joe to a full travel mug of specialty coffee. The thermal carafe is stainless steel to keep a full 12 cups of liquid at the perfect temperature just for you. The list goes on and on!

For those hot summer days, this coffeemaker can brew at lowered temperatures over ice to produce cold-brew beverages. Not only that, but the foldaway frother makes coffeehouse-quality froth and cream for an added yum factor, great for iced lattes or hot cappuccinos. To make things better, all of this is done without using a single pod – straight into your cup or into the thermal carafe.

In fact, the only reason this is not our number one pick is because of the price. This premium machine costs almost $300 dollars, making it rather pricey just for a coffee machine. That being said, if you have the money to splurge and love sipping on a wide variety of caffeinated drinks, Ninja’s Hot & Cold Brewed System might be the best pick for you.


  • Compatible with tea and coffee
  • Makes amazing iced beverages
  • Brews in six sizes, single cup to travel mug
  • Five different brewing styles , including rich/cold brew
  • Comes with integrated foldaway frother
  • Separated coffee & tea baskets

We like

  • The high quality stainless steel carafe
  • The outstanding amount of options for brew style/brew size
  • The ability to make hot, cold, or specialty drinks
  • It is extremely easy to use w/ smart systems

We don’t like

  • The price is extremely high
  • There is no hot plate
  • Takes a little long to brew

Check Todays Price

Our Pick

It’s hard to say anything bad about the Classic Thermal Programmable Coffeemaker from Cuisinart. This is an effective and trustworthy coffee-making machine. It comes with tons of settings, allowing you to brew various sizes of coffee. It is programmable. It self-cleans. It just simply works.

The Cuisinart comes with the best thermal carafe, available in either black or white. Also, the carafe is glass and double-walled to keep your coffee fresh and hot for hours after it is brewed. While all the coffeemakers on our list are high quality, nothing beats Cuisinart’s classic coffee machine and its strong thermal carafe.

About your author

Evelyn J. Stafford

Evelyn J. Stafford

Evelyn is a kitchen enthusiast and writer for Wins Coffee Bar. Her work has appeared in Bean Scene, The Home Kitchen and other publications.

Read moreTwitterEmail