Keurig vs Ninja – The Latest Side by Side
Keurig vs Ninja – the battle between these two coffee Giants and their premium coffee makers is nothing new. Keurig and Ninja both produce the world’s most popular home coffee machines, turning millions of people into their own personal baristas. Today we see who’s best.
From Keurig we have the K-Café, which is one of their higher end coffee makers. From Ninja we have the Specialty Coffee Maker, Keurig’s direct competition. Both of these machines are going to make delicious and full-flavored lattes, coffees, and even cappuccinos. Both are more expensive than the slim, single-serving models. That said, both are worth the price. But what should you buy, Keurig or Ninja?
Don’t Feel Like Reading? Our quick answer – go with the Ninja. Around the same price bracket, the Ninja offers more useful features and can brew up to a full Carafe. Click here to check it out on Amazon.
Overview of Keurig vs Ninja
Trying to establish which is better, the Keurig or the Ninja, is like trying to figure out who has the best burgers in town. All the options are great, but one of them is definitely superior. The Keurig and Ninja both make coffee, they both have frothers, and they both produce mouth-watering coffee. But the Ninja does it better.
|Ninja Specialty Coffee Maker|
|Combine rich Coffee concentrates with hot or cold frothed milk to craft in cafe style coffee|
|Delay Brew Timer|
|6 Brew Sizes|
|4 Brew Types|
|Fold Away Frother|
|Single or Carafe|
|1 Year Warranty|
|Keurig K-Cafe Coffee Maker|
|Enjoy the rich, full-flavored coffee you love or coffeehouse beverages from the K-Café|
|No Delay Timer|
|4 Cup Sizes|
|4 Brew Types|
|Single Serve Only|
|1 Year Warranty|
How does the Ninja do it better? Well, a few things. First, the Ninja lets you make a full pot of coffee. No messing around with any single serving bologna, especially on tough mornings when you want to have a cup of coffee, another cup of coffee, and then fill your travel mug and go to work.
And another thing. The Ninja has a clock. This may seem like a silly feature, but many of us grew up getting our time from the coffee maker in the kitchen. It just feels natural. Besides, with the Ninja you can pre-program your coffee to be ready in the morning. That, at least to us, is worth all the money in the world!
As a final note, in a society where being environmentally friendly is becoming more and more critical, less is more. Not having to use pods to get the coffee with your Ninja Specialty is a huge deal. We thank Ninja for this.
#1 – Features
Just like any other coffee maker from Keurig, the K-Café allows you to use any K-Cup pod available online or at your local supermarket. And while this gives you seemingly infinite possibilities – coffee, tea, hot chocolate – this particular Keurig is especially great at making milky drinks, like a full-flavored cappuccino.
This is thanks to the Keurig’s advanced frothing capabilities. All you need is a Keurig K-Cup pod and some fresh milk to create the creamiest latte ever, and in your own home. The frother is not only safe to use in the dishwasher, but it even features a setting to be used with cold milk.
Like Ninja and Nespresso (seen in our Nespresso vs Keurig comparison), Keurig is tall enough for you to effortlessly fill up a travel mug.
You can also brew ground coffee by using the special Keurig universal coffee filter, which is sold separately. The button controls are easy to use. The water reservoir is an impressive 60 ounces, which lets you brew 6 full cups of Joe before you need a refill of water. The reservoir is also removable for easy cleaning.
Unlike other Keurig models, the coffee maker heats the water and then brews the coffee in one quick process. No more waiting for the water to heat, wasting time in the morning.
#2 – Ease of Use
Keurig is notorious for having very simplistic coffee machines. The Keurig K-Café is no different. There are three simple buttons on the side, plus a few more buttons on the top, with a very easy-to-read circular selector to choose between single shot, or between 6 and 12 ounces.
For frothing, it is as easy as putting milk in the frother, either fresh cow’s milk, skim milk, soy milk, or almond milk, and then pushing a single button on the Keurig machine. Seconds later and you have tantalizing frothed milk to add to any beverage.
#3 – Brew Quality
The brew quality of the Keurig K-Café is excellent for any coffee drinker to enjoy an early steaming mug of java. Because this model of Keurig uses the normal K-Cups, you get the same level of superior taste that Keurig is known for the world over.
The brew quality is enhanced by the frother because it replicates barista-style lattes and cappuccinos. Also, there is now the “shot” mode. You can make a 2-ounce coffee shot that mimics the aroma and strength of a classical espresso.
#4 – Cleaning & Maintenance
Cleaning is exceptionally easy with the Keurig K-Café. The smart design allows components to come off and be cleaned by hand, while the frother can be cleaned inside your dishwasher.
There is almost no maintenance because you will always use the simple K-Cups. If you use ground coffee, all you need to do is clean the Keurig universal filter. You will never need to buy paper filters.
- Large variety for hot/cold drinks
- Dishwasher safe for easy clean
- Frother functions exceptionally
- Convenient to use, no hassle
- Mimics coffeeshop-quality espresso & latte
- Auto-off may trip circuit breaker
- Not that attractive
- K-Cup pods are not great for environment
- Only single-serving
- Frother may be confusing to operate
Ninja Specialty Fold-Away Frother
#1 – Features
Ninja is always striving to make the best coffee maker money can buy, and their new fold-away frother coffee maker is the epitome of this. You get 6 useful brew sizes, ranging from a single espresso to an entire travel mug, all the way to an entire carafe full of rich coffee. Ninja thought of everything.
The Ninja Specialty does exactly what the name suggests; it lets you make specialty coffees, anything from a macchiato to a cappuccino. The high-quality frother adds to the flavor and creamy taste of these specialty beverages. The frother can handle hot milk or cold milk and can even be folded out of the way.
The best thing about the Ninja Specialty is its dedication to being environmentally friendly. This means the filter is permanent and there is no need for pods. Ninja allows you to use your own favorite coffee grounds rather than polluting the Earth by filling your garbage with pods. It also comes with a glass carafe that can hold 50 ounces.
The Ninja, unlike the Keurig, has a programmable brew. This means your coffee is ready and waiting when you crawl out of bed in the morning (or afternoon).
#2 – Ease of Use
The Ninja is one of the easiest coffee makers you can use. It has a series of buttons accompanied by pictures on the front, making selection very easy. The big parts fold away so that you don’t have to deal with them. Plus, it has a clock. You can program your coffee to brew at any time.
#3 – Brew Quality
One thing people are always raving about is the surprising quality of coffee they get when using the Ninja Specialty. Many people prefer to use the Ninja than to buy their coffee from a coffee shop. The taste is that good. You get rich coffee in dark or light roast and refreshing ice beverages with soft foam.
Additionally, the Ninja Specialty Coffee Maker can emulate the exact consistency of cream used in most cafés using the folding frother. They can even emulate the espresso flavor for hardcore coffee drinkers. These features are similar to the Keurig K-Café.
#4 – Cleaning and Maintenance
Cleaning has never been easier than with the Ninja Specialty. This is because so many parts fold away. The frother is easy to unfold and clean, then put back into place. The water reservoir is removable for easy washing, and the glass carafe is much nicer to maintain than the metal coffee pots of the past.
You will have a hard time finding any scathing reviews about the Ninja Specialty or its maintenance. It’s simply a good system and that’s that. You don’t need to use paper filters, you don’t have to mess around with coffee pods, and because of its smart design there is minimal maintenance required.
- Programable brewing
- No pods / Eco friendly
- Measured reservoir
- Measured coffee scoop
- Reusable coffee filter
- Beeps when brewed
- Cold froth only
- No froth drip tray
- Less portable
- Produces a lot of steam
- More parts than Keurig
- Can’t make tea
Our Coffee Maker Conclusion
In our opinion, the Ninja wins this battle every single day of the week. Keurig vs Ninja is a no brainer. The craziest thing to us is the price. The Ninja costs significantly less than the Keurig even though it comes with more features.
The Ninja allows you to wake up with your coffee already brewed, to have your coffee in a full pot, and to make delicious iced specialty beverages with a hideaway frother. The Ninja is smarter for the environment, it’s easier to clean, and it has fewer customer complaints of short circuiting their breaker. For us, we love the Ninja Specialty Coffee Maker.